In my last post I quoted Jack Welsh as asserting that "There's No Such Thing as Work-Life Balance."
Trying to "balance" work and life is very difficult, which is why the topic generates so much discussion. Doing both at once requires constant effort and calculation: "Thursday I'll leave the office early and catch Timmy's soccer game, but Saturday I'll play golf with my colleagues...I'll go on the business trip next week, but I'll make sure to leave early and get home in time for dinner the week after that..."
You might be able to strike a balance that works for you - and that's the whole point of course - but being a model employee in a traditional professional setting just isn't compatible with being a model parent. Don't believe me? Consider the following profiles:
Being A Great Employee
Those who are model employees (and future executives) are those who are dedicated, reliable, hard working and well connected. This means that you are the one in at 7am and still in at 7pm, doing anything and everything that needs doing. You are the one who can be counted on to come in on the weekend to finish a big project. You take time to train and mentor others. You are always trying to improve, always excelling - and you are continually on the lookout for ways to minimize costs or increase revenue.
You never turn down an invitation to socialize with colleagues. You are spending time after work and on weekends networking, attending industry events, sitting on boards, playing golf with colleagues or the competition. You are constantly on the lookout for ways to impress and get friendly with your boss. You grab any opportunity to get more development or training even if it's an out of town seminar; you plan your social life around rubbing elbows with important people in your field;
Being A Great Parent
Those who are model parents are a constant reliable presence in their kids lives, consciously monitoring and assisting their development. They never miss a teaching moment, have the time and patience to properly discipline their kids, and keep their children engaged and stimulated.
They're scouring the internet for the safest, best, most cost effective crib/stroller/bike. They're analyzing the household budget to trim excess and make room for extracurriculars and college savings plans. They prepare three balanced meals a day for their kids. They somehow manage to keep their kids and homes clean and safe.
With small kids they play games so their brains develop properly, shower them with attention so they don't develop emotional attachment disorders, take them to parks and activities to get exercise, supervise play dates so they learn proper social interaction and read to them.
Older kids need help with homework so they maintain a decent GPA and get shuttled to as many valuable extracurriculars as possible so maybe they can get into a decent college one day. They need supervision so they don't end up pregnant or on drugs. They may be resentful and rebellious but you persevere, enforcing rules and checking in and meeting their friends' parents and not being afraid to embarass them - or yourself - in the process.
Comparison
To me the Model Employee sounds like the much easier job! Both can consume 100% of your attention and energy, but the Employee has more tangible rewards - respect at work, recognition in the way of bonuses and promotions, and the security of a benefits plan and salary.
The Model Parent doesn't have as much control along the way or security in the outcome of his or her efforts. Of course you CAN be a parent and work at the same time - millions of people do. But I think we can all agree that it's impossible to reach your full potential in either capacity when trying to balance your time and focus in both areas at once.
July 13, 2009
Model Employee vs Model Parent
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


8 comments:
Actually, it depends on the kind of career you have. The corporate success model is definitely not compatible with leaving room for model parenting.
But other kinds of careers, like non-profits or government work, are more "family-friendly", although the financial perks are far less. I think it has to do in part with the fact that gov't work has a lot of rules around what can and cannot be demanded of employees, and a seniority (rather than merit) based career ascension.
And non-profits rely on the hard work ethic of their employees, and respond with flexibility since they can'tt respond with pay.
@ Anon - certainly other career models, especially working from home or freelancing and even in some cases being an entrepreneur, are much more compatible with being a full-time parent.
But if you're on a traditional professional path, the demands and expectations just aren't there (though that may be slowly changing as younger people demand more flexibility and technology enables us to work from anywhere).
it's an interesting topic, though I would argue (as anon touched on) that it depends on the corporate environment. In my job, if you have to put in mega-hours per day, you're doing it wrong and folks will look askance at your inability to time-plan and budget your priorities. But that is my company - and it is culturally-family-friendly. I'm a first-time parent of a 2yr old, so I am living the imbalance right now - and needing the stability of a low-stress/non-time-intensive career at such an employer limits my willingness to pursue other opportunities that might be more fulfilling, but ultimately more challenging and require more of a time investment.
I agree that the work-life balance certainly requires compromise, but I also agree with the other commenters and feel it's not as dramatic as you suggest.
I feel the "traditional professional" career you describe is a very small segment of the job market, and ever growing smaller. I work in a technical field that I would consider "professional," and sucking up to my boss and colleagues through rounds of golf won't get me too far. In addition, flexible hours and working from home are common in my field, and I honestly I don't think the model employee cannot be one that sometimes leaves early to pick up kids or like spending the weekend with their family.
On the parenting side, I certainly think it's possible to be a great parent without researching strollers, cooking meals and cleaning the house all day, particularly if you have the help of a second parent.
I definitely think if you're on the CEO/executive path in a large fortune 500 company, it is hard or nearly impossible to be a model employee and parent. That's why most of those have a stay-at-home parent, plus maids and nannies.
However, many people I know have a satisfying professional career even up to the level of manager or director, and are capable, loving parents. They may not spend hours and hours with their kids but they definitely seem to be able to be a model worker and a good parent.
A lot depends on your field, your company, child's temperment, how many children you have, your spouse's support, etc..
At any rate, I definitely plan to work and have kids, without guilt!
I think that you need to separate the work "great" and "model" in your examples. I think you can be a great parent without fulfilling everything in your "model" parent. And I would say the same for your employee example.
It is not quite as black and white as you seem to be making it out to be. There are many careers (traditional professional paths can be found at non profits) that allow you to be a good parent and climb the ladder at work.
Obviously it's not black and white - but this is a contrast of the ways an IDEAL employee (for the stated purpose of quick and far advancement up the corporate ladder) would use her time and energy vs a an ideal parent (who would by definition sacrifice many of the extras that might get you ahead at work in order to actually see the kids during the 12 hours they are awake).
Of course you can do both, and you can do both reasonably well - especially if you're satisfied with your job and not looking for any big raises or promotions (which lots of people are and that's ok).
Please rewrite this post after you have children. You have so much to learn.
Post a Comment